Hardware RAID VS Software RAID

October 18, 2021

Introduction

RAID, also known as Redundant Array of Independent Disks is a system to ensure data availability, performance, and reliability. In the market, there are two types of RAID systems, hardware RAID, and software RAID. While both RAID systems have their advantages and disadvantages, we hope this article will help you decide the one that is best for you.

Hardware RAID

Hardware RAID works through a dedicated purpose-built RAID card that connects to the motherboard of the server through a storage array. It is a separate unit with its processor, memory, and operating system that manages the RAID.

Advantages

  • High performance, using a dedicated processor
  • Offers a more complex, configurable RAID setup process
  • Less CPU usage, as the RAID card manages everything

Disadvantages

  • Expensive compared to software RAID.
  • As it is hardware specific, replacing or upgrading can be challenging.

Software RAID

Software RAID is a software system that is pre-built into the operating system. It allows the server's CPU to manage the RAID system, eliminating the need for a separate card.

Advantages

  • Cost-efficient compared to hardware RAID.
  • More flexible as it depends on the host’s CPU capabilities.
  • Easier replacement or upgrading of drives compared to hardware RAID.

Disadvantages

  • Compared to hardware RAID, there is a performance lag because of CPU usage
  • Limited configuration options

Conclusion

When choosing between Hardware RAID and Software RAID, it is essential to consider your budget, the type of server you have, and your server's usage. If you have a high budget, require high performance, and better RAID configuration, Hardware RAID is the best option. On the other hand, if you're on a lower budget and require a flexible and easy to replace option in case of a failure, Software RAID is the clear winner.

So, which RAID system do you prefer? Let us know in the comments.

References


© 2023 Flare Compare